HEAR ME OUT: What if we actually did have second-class citizens?
asserted
we → hear → citizens
That, more or less, is what many people thought Carlos Eduardo Espina, the influencer darling of prominent Democrats with a following more than 24 million strong, proposed when Donald Trump briefly teased his openness to an immigration deal.
asserted
Trump → think → deal
Espina, 27, is a self-described millionaire, and he often pays bills for people from the Latino and immigrant communities who reach out to him.
asserted
who → describe → him
His generosity and large audience give him some weight in Democratic politics.
asserted
generosity → give → politics
But that doesn’t mean everyone likes it when he throws that weight around on policy issues.
asserted
he → mean → issues
Espina’s post floating a pathway to legal status for undocumented immigrants premised on denying the full rights of citizenship through a permanent bar on voting sparked a firestorm that engulfed much of the immigration-focused commentariat.
asserted
that → float → commentariat
He’s hardly the first person to float the idea of legalizing undocumented immigrants without providing a path to full citizenship.
asserted
He → ’ → citizenship
Yet coming from Espina—even as a thought experiment—this proposal caused an uproar.
asserted
proposal → come → uproar
The conflagration provides an illustration of the great challenge that immigration leaders and the larger Democratic coalition face as they move from broadly opposing Trump’s extreme policies to determining what they should positively and specifically advocate for to replace them.
asserted
they → provide → them
Espina’s post departs from the customary approach immigration leaders take to policy advocacy, which involves a lot of coming together to hash out differences within a coalition before presenting the public with a consensus position.
asserted
which → depart → position
And many who favor this method of operating were quick to let Espina know what they thought of his freelancing.
asserted
they → favor → freelancing
In response to Espina’s post, the Congressional Black Caucus questioned if immigrant-rights groups were now dropping voting as a key demand, a source with knowledge of these conversations told me.
asserted
source → question → me
“We must ask for a path to residency and citizenship,” wrote Ade Ferro, a Democratic organizer and activist in South Florida.
asserted
Ferro → ask → Florida
We are not creating second-class citizens.”
asserted
We → create → citizens
Erika Andiola, a well-known Dreamer activist and a veteran of the immigration policy wars dating back to the Obama years, also criticized Espina’s hypothetical compromise.
asserted
Andiola → know → compromise
Can we take your right away from voting or running for office for the rest of your life and then we can do it for millions of other people?
asserted
we → take → people
It makes me so sad to see this,” she wrote in a now-deleted thread of replies.
asserted
she → make → replies
“Why would you start publicly advocating for such an awful negotiation right now?
asserted
you → start → negotiation
Journalist Arturo Dominguez offered a cutting summary of Espina’s proposal: “denizenship.”
asserted
Dominguez → offer → proposal
Such a status has ugly historical precedents, he argued.
asserted
he → have → precedents
“More times than not they maintain a scapegoat status,” Dominguez told me.
asserted
Dominguez → maintain → me
“When you have immigrants contributing, paying taxes, and assimilating but they don’t have a voice in electoral politics, that makes them very vulnerable.”
asserted
them → have → politics
It’s like “going back to the Jim Crow era.”
asserted
It → ’ → era
FOR HIS PART, Espina has not been deterred by the blowback.
asserted
Espina → deter → blowback
Trump was president when he was in high school, he reminded me; coming up in a time defined by openly hostile, even belligerent politics means that fighting back comes naturally to him.
asserted
fighting → remind → him
That’s especially the case when he feels he’s speaking up for undocumented immigrants.
asserted
he → ’ → immigrants
He tells me that many from across the country, from Florida to Texas to California, see his proposal as something worth considering.
asserted
many → tell → something
“This post made a lot of ‘immigrant rights activist’ upset, but what’s interesting is that I posed the same question on Facebook to the immigrants who would be affected by this, and after 20 hours, the post has 2.3 million views, 36k likes, and almost 6k comments overwhelmingly supporting the proposed policy,” he wrote.
asserted
he → make → policy
“I guess it shows how out of touch a lot of activists are with the communities they pretend to care about and represent.
asserted
they → guess → communities
Maybe that’s why nothing ever gets done!”
asserted
nothing → ’ → ?
Thomas Kennedy, a Florida-based immigration activist who has worked with the families of men detained in places like “Alligator Alcatraz” and the Krome detention center, offered a terse reply to Espina’s post: “Good job creating division and trying to weaken negotiations before they even start.”
asserted
they → base → negotiations
His anger was palpable when I spoke to him.
asserted
I → speak → him
“[Espina’s] demeanor is so arrogant, the lack of assuming best intentions, lack of ability to have a mature dialogue, the likes and comments have gone to his head,” Kennedy told me.
asserted
Kennedy → assume → me
“The way he dismisses undocumented people and activists, like ‘I’m the authority here, it’s my way or the highway.’
asserted
it → dismiss → people
It’s also about who gets to lead an immigration movement that, notwithstanding a few individual successes—the creation of DACA, some TPS renewals—has undergone repeated bitter disappointments.
asserted
that → ’ → disappointments
Many who spoke up to criticize Espina’s plan told me the influencer had committed a cardinal sin against the movement.
asserted
influencer → speak → movement
“You never talk about denying voting rights; the entire history of social justice is about expanding voting rights,” a prominent activist with a national profile told me, asking for anonymity in exchange for candor.
asserted
activist → talk → candor
“It’s ignorant and frankly stupid to say ‘Deny voting rights to nonwhite people’ when any social justice cause is about expanding voting rights for nonwhite people.
asserted
cause → ’ → people
An added wrinkle: Espina has acknowledged that earlier in the year he was paid for some posts by Tom Steyer’s California gubernatorial campaign, and some activists who spoke with me suggested that someone may have paid for his recent post, too.
Espina told me the payola accusations are nonsense, and he characterized the tradeoff he suggested as better meeting the immediate needs of the sorts of people who follow him—the ones who come up to him in hotels, emerge from restaurant kitchens to shake his hand, and share stories with him of their families under assault by the Trump administration.
“People say I’m willing to give up the right to vote, but I’m not giving up anything because they don’t have that either way
uncertain
they → acknowledge → that
,” he told me.
asserted
he → tell → me
…and 33 more, not listed.