When The Hunger Games hit bookshelves nearly 20 years ago, it felt uncanny in its timeliness.
asserted
it → hit → timeliness
The megaselling young adult novel by Suzanne Collins posited a dystopian future America in which an ostentatiously rich and powerful central district known as the Capitol ruled over the outer territories, forcing children chosen by lottery to compete in a deadly game that also served as a patriotism-bolstering reality show.
asserted
that → megaselle → show
Arriving on the cusp of the financial crisis after years of increasingly grueling competition for top slots in prestigious colleges and growing concerns about inequality in a winner-take-all economy, it captured the mood, or perhaps moods, of the moment with eerie metaphorical precision.
asserted
it → arrive → precision
The answer was all of the above, and more, as the book and eventual series of movies starring Jennifer Lawrence became a cultural phenomenon, the Harry Potter of millennial angst.
asserted
book → star → angst
But even given the series' choose-your-own-metaphor versatility, it was easy to see it as a libertarian-tinged metaphor for the dangers of an authoritarian state.
asserted
it → give → state
The games were a government project, enforced and imposed by uniformed soldiers with guns on lowly subjects who were forced to toil in poverty to support the vulgarly glamorous lives of state officials.
asserted
who → enforce → officials
But after watching the latest film in the franchise, Sunrise on the Reaping, I'm not so sure whether the metaphor holds up.
asserted
metaphor → watch → Reaping
Set decades before the first Hunger Games, Sunrise on the Reaping tells the backstory of Haymitch Abernathy, the mentor-figure played by Woody Harrelson in the first film.
asserted
Sunrise → Set → film
Here, he's portrayed by Joseph Zada, who looks similar enough in the eyes but sadly lacks any of Harrelson's crotchety charisma.
asserted
who → portray → charisma
That becomes a problem for a movie that is fundamentally oriented around caring about its protagonists' suffering; Zada's Haymitch is simply a dud, so his (admittedly tragic and terrible) persecution evokes little more than a shrug.
asserted
persecution → become → shrug
Maybe he needs to smoke more weed.
asserted
he → need → weed
Half the lines read like Wikipedia plot summaries.
asserted
lines → read → summaries
The other half dutifully underline the movie's big themes of resistance, rebellion, and opposition to the dystopian terror of the games.
asserted
half → underline → games
No one ever talks like an ordinary person; every line is a margin note explaining what the scene is about.
asserted
scene → talk → what
And often enough, what the scene is about is taking down "the system."
asserted
is → take → system
The games, we're told, are "a machine," and Haymitch's goal is to destroy that machine.
asserted
goal → tell → machine
But often enough it seems like a stand-in for capitalism, with the games intended as a critique of society-wide, winner-take-all economic brutality.
asserted
games → seem → brutality
The metaphorical possibilities are too vast to pin the movie down, and the thinness of the movie's ideas renders definitive interpretation impossible.
asserted
interpretation → pin → ideas
But I did get the sense that its sympathies were with those who talk most about tearing apart the existing economic system.
asserted
who → get → system
By the end, when a devastated, drunken Haymitch vows to take it all down, as a long act of revenge against the system that destroyed all he loves, I half wondered whether his promise not to stop "until there's no more Capitol" was meant as a punny promise not to stop until there's no more capital.
asserted
promise → vow → promise
This would be fine if the movie weren't quite so sluggish, or if the stakes were higher: One of this overlong prequel's many problems is that we already know the fate of the Capitol and its murderous games.
asserted
we → know → Capitol
That might have been fine if more of the characters lit up the screen.
uncertain
more → light → screen
The first four films worked partly because of a who's-who of top-tier character actors, and partly because of Jennifer Lawrence's undeniable star power.
asserted
films → work → power
Here, Jesse Plemons, Kieran Culkin, and Elle Fanning turn in better-than-necessary supporting turns, but the central character and his story fizzle.
asserted
character → turn → turns
It's not a disaster, exactly, but it's a step down for the series, and it left me hungry for better Games.
asserted
it → leave → Games