Tenants in Madrid say Toronto-based Brookfield is pricing them out of formerly public housing
Canadian investment dollars are one of the villains in Spain's election fight over housing
asserted
dollars → say → housing
At a Madrid apartment complex just outside the city's centre, red maple leaves hang upside down in windows along with defiant posters urging Canadian investment money to get out of their neighbourhood.
asserted
leaves → hang → neighbourhood
"They are pushing us out of our houses," said Rafael Cuadrado, who has lived in the complex for 20 years.
asserted
who → push → years
The main target of the residents' wrath is Toronto-based Brookfield Corporation.
asserted
target → base → wrath
A sign on a window of a Madrid apartment accuses Toronto-based Brookfield of treating tenants unfairly.
asserted
sign → accuse → tenants
In a statement to CBC News, Brookfield said it complies with all 'applicable Spanish tenancy legislation, including statutory tenant protections and extension requirements.'
asserted
it → say → protections
One of Canada's premier financial and investment institutions, Brookfield owns 900 units in Cuadrado's residential complex, along with approximately 4,100 others around the Spanish capital.
asserted
Brookfield → own → capital
Cuadrado and other residents accuse Brookfield of planning to let their leases expire and then flip their homes for market prices that few here can afford.
asserted
few → accuse → that
He says several of his neighbours have already received notices from Brookfield's management company informing them their tenancies will not be extended.
asserted
tenancies → say → them
CBC News has seen one letter sent to a tenant who was told their expiring lease would not be renewed and they would have to turn over the keys to their apartment.
asserted
they → see → apartment
It's not illegal, but the residents say it's unfair.
asserted
it → say → ?
"Our daughter came here when she was two years old.
asserted
she → come → ?
This is our first house ... so this is our life," Cuadrado told CBC News in his living room.
asserted
Cuadrado → tell → room
Many of the residents are long-time tenants who moved into the buildings when they used to be part of Madrid's public housing stock.
asserted
they → move → stock
Most pay rents well below the current market rate, as a succession of lease extensions and government-mandated rent caps have kept their outlay relatively low.
asserted
succession → pay → outlay
Raphael Cuadrado lives in a Madrid apartment complex owned by Brookfield, one of Canada's top investment firms.
asserted
Cuadrado → live → firms
He and other residents fear the company plans to flip their units when their leases expire.
asserted
leases → fear → units
Cuadrado says he pays 930 euros a month for his 800-square-foot, three-bedroom apartment.
asserted
he → say → apartment
The unit would likely fetch about 1,500 euros on the open market.
asserted
unit → fetch → market
"Why do we have to leave our house because there is a big investment company coming from abroad to get a profit [from] us?" he said.
asserted
he → have → us
'Vulture funds'
Anger over housing in Spain has hit a breaking point.
asserted
Anger → hit → point
The eviction of Madrid resident Maricarmen Abascal in late September, after the 87-year-old woman was unable to pay a hefty rent increase, sent protesters into the streets.
asserted
woman → pay → streets
Authorities evicted her on the back of a stretcher and she died in hospital a few weeks later.
asserted
she → evict → hospital
Her eviction prompted Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez to call an election for Nov. 29, with housing the central issue.
asserted
housing → prompt → Nov.
Spain's public unions, which allied with the tenants, are casting money from institutional investors, such as pension plans, as one of the primary villains.
asserted
which → ally → villains
"'Vulture funds' are what they call them," said Alicia Del Rio, who is with Sindicato de Inquilinas de Madrid (Madrid Tenants Union), one of the country's most prominent advocates for renters.
asserted
who → call → renters
Del Rio blames a succession of cash-strapped Spanish governments for laying out the welcome mat for foreign investors, who she says have in turn treated Spanish residential properties as a commodity to be flipped, with little regard for the people living in them.
asserted
she → blame → them
"[The government] gave the message, 'Welcome to Spain, this is going to be your paradise.'"
asserted
this → give → Spain
Canadian owners
Canadian retirement funds and investment firms are designed to seek out safe returns — wherever they can find them.
asserted
they → design → them
And Spain is seen as an attractive place to grow that money.
asserted
Spain → see → money
Along with Brookfield, Canada Pension Plan Investments has a roughly 900-million-euro portfolio ($1.4 billion Cdn) in the Spanish housing sector, although it's focused on student housing rather than residential homes.
asserted
it → have → homes
It owns approximately 13,000 dorm-type beds across Spain and Portugal, concentrated in cities with large universities.
asserted
It → own → universities
In a statement to CBC News, CPP said its investments help "expand the overall supply of housing available to students without removing existing homes from the conventional residential market.
asserted
investments → say → market
"
HOOPP — Health Care of the Ontario Pension Plan — owns approximately 700 million euros ($1.1 billion Cdn) worth of Spanish properties, including 27 residential buildings and 2,300 Madrid homes.
asserted
HOOPP → own → buildings
The Spanish tenant unions haven't raised any specific concerns about HOOPP's activities or its properties.
asserted
unions → raise → activities
Whether foreign investment firms are cornering the country's housing market has become one of Spain's most fiercely debated issues.
asserted
cornering → corner → issues
Numbers from the Bank of Spain say institutional investors control only a tiny share — roughly two per cent — of the country's total housing stock.
asserted
investors → say → stock
The tenant unions, however, say the fact that many of those properties used to be public, non-market housing for middle- or lower-income families matters far more than their share of the national total.
asserted
many → say → total
Spain's Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez appears at a campaign rally in Palma de Mallorca on Nov. 14, ahead of the Nov. 29 general election.
asserted
Sanchez → appear → election
They also claim that the concentration of apartments in central areas of cities gives companies like Brookfield outsized power to drive up rents across entire neighbourhoods.
uncertain
concentration → claim → neighbourhoods
…and 32 more, not listed.