For more than thirty years, Maria José has lived in public housing in Los Angeles with her family.
asserted
José → live → family
Most of that time, the 66-year-old Mexican woman, who asked to go by a pseudonym due to her immigration status, has been a caretaker.
asserted
who → ask → status
First for her five children, who have since moved out and become independent.
asserted
who → move → children
Now, she takes care of her husband, a permanent resident who was partially paralyzed after a stroke around five years ago.
asserted
who → take → stroke
But an imminent change in federal housing policy means the couple could soon lose their home.
uncertain
couple → mean → home
They are among thousands of households who might have to decide between housing assistance or living without their immigrant family members this winter, because of an incoming change in federal housing policy.
uncertain
who → have → policy
This week, Union de Vecinos, a local tenants and community organizing group that Maria José is part of, joined a federal lawsuit contesting a new Department of Housing and Urban Development rule that will push family members without sufficient immigration status from Section 8 and public housing.
asserted
that → join → Section
Still, for decades, many have been able to live alongside their documented family members who do qualify for help.
asserted
who → live → help
Generally, mixed-status families pay more for housing than other beneficiaries—when providing subsidies, HUD only counts the family members who agree to verify their legal status.
asserted
who → mix → status
Maria José, for instance, says she pays a flat, monthly rent with help from her son, while her husband, who is the beneficiary, is only required to pay 30 percent of his monthly income.
asserted
who → say → income
The new rule, set to come into effect December 12, would get rid of this prorated option and require that all public housing assistance applicants and recipients verify their immigration status or lose support.
asserted
applicants → set → support
The policy change, the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities estimates, could push out nearly 80,000 people across the country out of their homes, including 36,900 children.
uncertain
Center → estimate → children
In the Federal Register, HUD said these amendments would help the federal agency “align with the current Administration’s priorities and regulatory reform efforts”—that is, with Trump’s immigration crackdown.
asserted
agency → say → crackdown
And the agency’s secretary, Scott Turner, has reiterated that the rule “guarantees only American citizens and certain eligible noncitizens will reside in HUD-funded housing,” and is “closing this decades-old loophole.”
asserted
citizens → reiterate → loophole
Housing and civil rights advocates counter that the rule would add further hardship to the lives of household members who do qualify.
asserted
who → counter → members
“Those are citizen children that now get evicted from their homes,” said Elizabeth Blaney, co-director of Union de Vecinos.
asserted
Blaney → evict → Vecinos
“Already, parents are struggling with trying to carry multiple jobs, and now you’ve just taken away another level of support for the family.
asserted
you → struggle → family
In April, two months after the rule was first proposed, a coalition of local governments urged HUD to withdraw it, worried about its impact on their vulnerable communities and how it would destabilize their broader affordable housing networks.
asserted
it → propose → networks
They also contended that the rule overrides a framework created by Congress to keep mixed-status families together.
asserted
rule → contend → families
“It’s unconstitutional,” Blaney said.
asserted
Blaney → ’ → ?
“They don’t have the right to discriminate in such a way and target residents, especially residents who are already paying higher rents.”
asserted
who → have → rents
In cities with affordable housing shortages and large immigrant populations, housing advocacy groups say the impact of the new rule would be especially stark.
asserted
impact → say → rule
In Los Angeles, where the plaintiffs are based, approximately 1,700 mixed-status families would be affected, according to city estimates.
uncertain
families → base → estimates
They would enter a market, some for the first time in years, that has an affordable housing shortage of more than 400,000 units, according to California Housing Partnership estimates.
uncertain
that → enter → estimates
“We already have a huge unhoused population here in LA, and we’re really concerned about the support that all of our community members will be able to receive if it is finalized,” said Cassidy Bennett, a staff attorney at Public Counsel, the nonprofit law firm leading the suit.
asserted
Bennett → have → suit
More broadly, California’s Civil Rights Department has reminded HUD that, according to the federal agency’s own analysis, the new policy would require additional spending to implement, meaning the number of public housing units and services available would decline as a result.
uncertain
number → remind → result
The rule would also, said the department’s director Kevin Kish, make it more difficult for the state to fight housing discrimination.
asserted
state → say → discrimination
As news of the policy spreads, tenants rights advocates like Blaney are working to remind families that the rule hasn’t been implemented and they don’t have to move out of their homes yet.
“Nobody should be self-evicting,” she emphasized.
asserted
she → spread → homes
Even after the rule comes into effect, cities will need time to determine how to implement it while groups like Union de Vecinos ensure they respect tenants’ other legal rights.
asserted
they → come → rights
And it’s possible the rule might be repealed during that time.
uncertain
rule → ’ → time
“We hope that the new Congress will rescind it,” Blaney said.
asserted
Blaney → hope → it
“People voted them in to support immigrant rights, and this is one thing that they can do to show that.”
asserted
they → vote → that
But as the rule stands, Bennett said she’s especially worried about the long-term impacts that losing housing stability could have on tenants, and how it would destabilize their communities.
uncertain
it → stand → communities
Two of the individual plaintiffs in the complaint, she noted, are US citizens with undocumented parents that have lived in public housing most of their lives.
asserted
that → note → lives
One is a young woman who has lived with her two brothers, her mom, and her stepdad for fifteen years.
asserted
who → live → years
Her younger brothers both want to finish school—and she is hoping to get her master’s degree too.
asserted
she → want → degree
If the rule passes, Bennett said all three would likely have to work full-time to help their family pay market-rate rent somewhere else, abandoning their studies.
asserted
family → pass → studies
The other is a 26-year-old man with cerebral palsy whose parents and sister have taken care of him in the same home since he was one year old.
asserted
he → take → home
He’s the only citizen in his family, and can’t live by himself, Bennett noted.
asserted
Bennett → ’ → himself
If the rule passes, the whole family would have to leave.
asserted
family → pass → ?