The Columbus Crew have a more holistic operation than most in MLS.
asserted
Crew → have → MLS
The club as a whole still exists thanks to the dogged efforts of their fervent fanbase that helped block relocation.
asserted
that → exist → relocation
Their under-19s won the national cup in June, while the developmental Crew 2 made a fourth semi-final berth in five seasons in MLS Next Pro.
asserted
Crew → win → Pro
The first team regularly punches above its weight in MLS, winning the third-most major titles (nine) among MLS originals.
asserted
team → punch → originals
And yet, this year tested the conventions set by team and league alike.
asserted
year → test → team
In January, chief soccer officer Issa Tall welcomed the club’s eighth head coach, Henrik Rydström.
asserted
Tall → welcome → coach
Having only previously coached in his native Sweden, the 50-year-old used his introductory presser to laud the values of relationism, to praise his predecessor, and to plot a bold course for a new Crew.
asserted
old → coach → Crew
It was assumed he’d be around a while – the Crew have historically been patient with coaches, needing only seven bosses to navigate their first 30 seasons.
asserted
Crew → assume → seasons
And yet, Saturday sees the Crew begin the MLS Cup Playoffs in a best-of-three matchup with Lionel Messi and Inter Miami.
asserted
Crew → see → Messi
Columbus are one of four teams to make the postseason following a midseason coaching change.
asserted
Columbus → make → change
Two of the other three could pin their turnarounds on players; Orlando City fired Óscar Pareja in March, but didn’t really shoot up the table until adding Antoine Griezmann after the World Cup.
uncertain
City → pin → Cup
The Philadelphia Union surged thanks to interim coach, Ryan Richter, finally seeing if Cavan Sullivan could cut it in MLS (he can).
uncertain
he → surge → MLS
The Portland Timbers’ turnaround after sacking Phil Neville might be closest to Columbus’ story, though 2026 was his third season in the role.
uncertain
2026 → sack → role
They weren’t at the start of a new path, and that path had not been decided after the departure of one of MLS’s most influential coaches to date: Wilfried Nancy.
asserted
path → decide → date
“Wilfield had a huge impact on our club, and him departing is certainly not an easy thing to move on from,” Tall told the Guardian.
asserted
Tall → have → Guardian
But then there were things that we believed we could do better, whether it’s on the alignment of the scouting department, or even on the way the players are managed.
uncertain
players → be → way
There are ways you can evolve.”
asserted
you → be → ?
Two Nancy acolytes seemed like obvious fits.
asserted
acolytes → seem → fits
One, Laurent Courtois, led the second team from 2022-2024 and had a brief sojourn as head coach of CF Montreal.
asserted
One → lead → Montreal
Another, Yoann Damet, was Nancy’s top assistant and had long been earmarked as a head coach in the making.
asserted
Another → earmark → making
According to Tall, conversations with Damet left both coach and executive in a sense that it was best for Damet’s development to explore options beyond Columbus.
uncertain
it → accord → Columbus
“At the end of the year, Yoann already had [done] some rounds [of interviews] with St Louis [City],” Tall said.
asserted
Tall → do → Louis
“We all agreed that it’d be better for him to go to another club and become the head coach and the leader, as opposed to maybe always being seen as the former assistant coach”.
asserted
him → agree → coach
Damet took that chance, setting up shop roughly 400 miles down I-70.
asserted
Damet → take → I-70
His first season with St Louis has been transformative, leading the team to their first major trophy by winning the Lamar Hunt US Open Cup and finishing third in the West.
asserted
season → lead → West
Despite determination to install a new coach before preseason kicked off in early January, Tall, technical director Marc Nicholls, and the rest of the Crew’s committee didn’t want to cut corners.
asserted
Tall → install → corners
“The first one is really, ‘who are you’?” Tall said.
asserted
Tall → say → ?
“‘I’ve read about you, I’ve seen your team play, but what are your guiding principles as a person?’
asserted
principles → read → person
In that first round you eliminate a lot of candidates because, based on the answer and maybe being egocentric or selfish, you can tell that they’re not a good fit.
asserted
they → eliminate → answer
“In the second round, you go more in-depth about the club and the coach.
asserted
you → go → club
Then, third, is really going into deep details of everything in terms of preparations and so forth.”
asserted
third → go → preparations
Rydström seemed to fit the bill.
asserted
Rydström → seem → bill
Tall and Nancy had often admired his teams at Mälmo, which played with similar panache and kept the team punching above their weight class in the Allsvenskan.
asserted
team → admire → Allsvenskan
Conversations were productive, with Tall citing Mauricio Sarri’s Napoli sides as a shared inspiration.
asserted
Tall → cite → inspiration
On 31 December, Tall and Rydström signed a pact – new year, new Crew.
asserted
Tall → sign → pact
However, it was clear early on that the roster wasn’t adjusting as expected.
asserted
roster → adjust → ?
Columbus took two points from their first five games, but the concerns were even more foundational – less Sarri, more sorry.
asserted
concerns → take → games
“I’ve been fortunate to be in many locker rooms, and I can feel the dynamic between players and staff,” Tall reflected.
asserted
Tall → feel → players
“If things don’t feel right, you could play the ostrich and pretend it’s okay.
uncertain
it → feel → ostrich
Give yourself another year and if it doesn’t work, it may be time to make a change.
uncertain
it → give → change
…and 20 more, not listed.