The University of Toronto has done something rare for a Canadian university: it published a report from its own equity working group and simultaneously declined to adopt it.
asserted
it → do → it
“Over-Policed, Under-Protected,” the final report of U of T’s Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian Discrimination Working Group (MAP DWG), was released Nov. 12 alongside the administration’s formal response.
asserted
Protected → protect → response
The working group, chaired by law professor Anver Emon, made 57 recommendations.
asserted
group → work → recommendations
President Melanie Woodin and Provost Trevor Young wrote that the university “cannot accept” them “as written.”
asserted
university → write → them
The report’s chair, Anver Emon, has called the decision “startling” and told NOW Toronto the response was “actually a little bit racist.”
asserted
response → call → Toronto
But a close read of both documents shows an administration drawing a line: an equity review, it argues, cannot become a vehicle for rewriting the university’s rules on academic freedom, institutional neutrality, and campus speech—rules Jewish students and faculty have needed to rely on heavily since Oct. 7, 2023.
asserted
students → show → Oct.
What the working group found
The group held 85 consultations and ran a survey that drew 525 responses; 44 percent of respondents did not identify as Muslim, Arab, or Palestinian.
asserted
percent → work → respondents
Some of the discrimination the group’s report documents is real, and the university does not dispute that.
asserted
university → document → that
Respondents described being ridiculed for wearing a hijab, being called “terrorist,” and having flyers and personal property vandalized.
asserted
flyers → describe → hijab
Others reported online profiling by outside groups such as Canary Mission and a “chilling effect” on pro-Palestinian expression in classrooms.
asserted
Others → report → classrooms
The report’s central claim is that U of T shows “a general pattern of over-policing and under-protecting speech, research, and advocacy by or on Muslims, Arabs, and especially Palestinians,” and that its commitment to critical research suffers from a “Palestine exception.”
uncertain
commitment → show → exception
What it recommended
asserted
recommended → recommend → What
Others reach much further.
asserted
Others → reach → ?
The report asked the provost to strip references to the University of Chicago’s 1967 Kalven Report from U of T’s memo on institutional statements and “expressly reject its principle of institutional neutrality.”
asserted
report → ask → neutrality
It would have also removed academic freedom and free speech as stated justifications for that memo.
asserted
It → remove → memo
It called for a study of the impact of military personnel as instructors, “particularly service-people from militaries whose leadership and/or actions are subject to investigation under the Rome Statute.”
asserted
leadership → call → Statute
The report makes clear this includes Israeli reservists.
asserted
includes → make → reservists
It cited concerns about an Israel Defense Forces reservist who left a visiting professorship after Oct. 7, 2023, to serve in Gaza and resumed teaching in fall 2024.
asserted
who → cite → fall
It wanted the university to “condemn” online platforms with a foreign-government nexus.
asserted
university → want → nexus
It asked for the province’s appointees to the Governing Council to receive special guidance on the risks their status poses to institutional autonomy, and for every governor to complete anti-Muslim, anti-Arab, and anti-Palestinian discrimination training before taking their seat.
asserted
governor → ask → seat
It also wanted faculty social media posts presumed to be protected academic freedom.
asserted
posts → want → ?
The list went further still.
asserted
list → go → ?
Deans, it recommended, would have to file a complaint with the relevant licensing body whenever a licensed professional, such as a practicum supervisor, refuses to complete a student’s placement because they disagree with the student’s “otherwise legitimate and lawful speech, political views, or assembly choices.
asserted
they → recommend → speech
On doxing, the report asks U of T to: bar hiring committees from considering online doxing sites; tell employers recruiting on campus not to withdraw job or internship offers from doxed students; lobby government to better regulate search engines such as Google.
asserted
report → ask → Google
It asked the university to limit the fees it withholds from the graduate students’ union over its BDS Caucus to what the caucus actually spends.
asserted
caucus → ask → what
On Palestinian students and scholars, it wanted U of T to fully fund at-risk Palestinian undergraduates, with preference for applicants from Gaza, the West Bank, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Egypt, and Palestinian citizens of Israel.
asserted
U → want → Israel
It also asked for expanded partnerships with Palestinian universities, preferably in Gaza.
asserted
It → ask → Gaza
It wanted university guidance to state that treating keffiyehs, the call to prayer, or ululations as evidence of a security threat “is a form of bias and harassment.”
asserted
treating → want → bias
The annual discrimination-complaints report required under Ontario’s Bill 166 would record the race, ethnic origin, and religious identity of respondents as well as complainants.
asserted
report → require → respondents
And “projections” would be removed from the list of postering examples that count as vandalism.
asserted
that → remove → vandalism
The report also urged U of T to consider an absolute ban on investments tied to violations of “peremptory norms of international law,” and frames much of its analysis around international bodies that have described Israel’s conduct in Gaza as apartheid or genocide.
asserted
that → urge → apartheid
It also faulted intervenors in the university’s 2024 court case against the encampment—including a Hillel U of T executive—for reading the word “intifada” through “the narrow lens of security and threat to Israelis and Jews.”
asserted
It → fault → Israelis
Why U of T rejected adopting the report’s recommendations
The administration gave five reasons.
asserted
administration → reject → reasons
Some recommendations “conflict with collective agreements and protections for faculty members’ academic freedom.”
asserted
recommendations → conflict → freedom
Others, on hospitals, school boards, and government, “fall outside the University’s jurisdiction.”
asserted
Others → fall → jurisdiction
Parts of the report raise “specific and unattributed allegations, some of which reflect a single individual’s perspective.”
asserted
some → raise → perspective
Elements are “not congruent with U of T’s position of institutional restraint,” which the university says lets people “express multiple and divergent viewpoints.”
asserted
people → say → viewpoints
And the report “contains lengthy commentary about events abroad rather than focusing on proposals to improve University life.”
asserted
report → contain → life
The response also warned that while the report will validate many people’s experiences, aspects “will also be offensive and upsetting to other members of our community, including some Jewish and Israeli colleagues and students.”
asserted
aspects → warn → colleagues
The report states in its own voice that international bodies have found Israel is committing, “if not genocide against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, widespread crimes against humanity.”
asserted
Israel → state → humanity
…and 34 more, not listed.