In 4500 words, Cameron Bancroft got very granular.
asserted
Bancroft → get → words
He relayed verbatim conversations with Darren Lehman and David Saker about getting sandpaper onto the ground.
asserted
He → relay → ground
Indeed, he recounted multiple Saker conversations.
asserted
he → recount → conversations
He described numerous conversations with David Warner, who suggested sandpaper be used in the first place.
uncertain
sandpaper → describe → place
And he described the all care, no responsibility – in fact no care, no responsibility – attitude of Steve Smith rushing away, hands aloft.
asserted
hands → describe → attitude
He recalled the very words of his conversations with media manager Kate Hutchison – one of the few to emerge well from this soap opera – about using sandpaper.
asserted
He → recall → sandpaper
Then he got to Pat Cummins and the bowlers, and he suddenly became very vague.
asserted
he → get → Cummins
He shifted from Geoffrey Robertson to Dennis Denuto; his account went from granular to “oh, they all knew”.
asserted
they → shift → Denuto
Maybe they did.
asserted
they → do → ?
It stretches credibility to think the people who hold the ball more than others, and consider it like a craftsman a favourite chisel, did not notice differences in the ball.
asserted
who → stretch → ball
But seeing change and knowing what caused it are two different things.
asserted
what → see → it
In his lengthy account, Bancroft goes from smoking gun to deductive leap.
asserted
Bancroft → go → leap
And those reading it likewise appear to have joined in the same “oh, of course they did” conclusion.
asserted
they → read → conclusion
It might be thought Bancroft’s sudden mid-rant vagueness was to protect the remnants of a broken relationship with the bowlers and Cummins in particular, but Bancroft had already gone out of his way to individualise Cummins and talk of his anger with him.
uncertain
Bancroft → think → him
The angry man seems unlikely to pull a punch, unless he can’t remember a punch he can throw.
asserted
he → seem → punch
Bancroft’s stated aim in his 4000-word recounting was to tell all.
asserted
aim → state → all
That is not consistent with him holding back the single most important bit of knowledge or incriminating specific anecdote indicating what the current Australian captain knew about the team’s use of sandpaper back in 2018.
asserted
captain → hold → 2018
The logical extension of Bancroft suddenly falling back on “they all knew” is that his memory permits no more than assumption.
asserted
memory → fall → assumption
It was a logical assumption, but set against the strident, unequivocal and detailed denials from Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, the assumption must carry less weight.
asserted
assumption → set → weight
Like Bancroft, Chadd Sayers was prompted to speak out in defence of Usman Khawaja because of their anger at Cummins’ decision to personalise his defence by talking of Khawaja being casual with their friendship.
asserted
Khawaja → prompt → friendship
But then neither of them cited a specific moment from Cummins, or any of the other bowlers, that acknowledged the use of sandpaper.
asserted
that → cite → sandpaper
Everyone has acknowledged, even the bowlers, that the team worked on the ball.
asserted
team → acknowledge → ball
They all knew Warner was manipulator-in-chief.
asserted
Warner → know → chief
But not that sandpaper was used.
asserted
sandpaper → use → ?
The only way to know that someone knows something, as distinct from assuming they know, is to have been witness to them seeing it, hearing it or of them telling you they know.
asserted
they → know → you
None of Bancroft, Warner, Khawaja or Sayers have offered such a moment about the bowlers.
asserted
None → offer → bowlers
That is interesting because Bancroft goes out of his way to say in his lengthy statement that there is a difference between knowing the ball was being worked on and sandpaper being used.
asserted
sandpaper → go → knowing
“I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used,” he said.
asserted
he → recognise → knowing
He understands the importance of the distinction but then offers nothing concrete to support it.
asserted
He → understand → it
He does not say how he knows the bowlers knew it was sandpaper.
asserted
it → say → ?
He does not say – as he did of others – I know they knew because we directly spoke about it on this day.
asserted
we → say → day
Being aware of the important distinction and then failing to attempt to say which category Cummins and each bowler fell into is instructive.
asserted
Cummins → fail → category
Bancroft may well have further incriminating stories to tell about this, but the point is he has not told them in his 4000-word statement.
uncertain
he → have → statement
Maybe they will do so at the closed door forum.
asserted
they → do → forum
Short of punishing the whole team (and there was genuine merit in Khawaja’s recommendation at the time that they say ‘we are all in on this’), the real upshot of the latest instalment in the issue is effectively that the three players punished by Cricket Australia remain the three most culpable players.
asserted
players → punish → Australia
Bancroft says it was Warner’s idea to use sandpaper, Warner admits it was his idea, but he couldn’t carry the paper because people were looking at him, and Smith knew but didn’t want to know.
asserted
Smith → say → him
As all have made clear, that a team was doctoring the ball was no surprise to anyone, least of all the South Africans or the English.
asserted
doctoring → make → all
But can we also take a moment to check on the moral arbiters Nasser Hussain and Michael Vaughan, the former England captains of two Ashes campaigns in which Marcus Trescothick outlined in his book how he had stocked his pockets so full of sticky mints it looked like he had developed a growth in his thighs?
asserted
he → take → thighs
Trescothick wondered at how he was never called out by the umpires for having so many of them and using them on the ball.
asserted
he → wonder → ball
They were brought onto the field for a very specific purpose, which was not to satisfy a diabetic need for sugar, but to load the ball up to swing.
asserted
which → bring → ball
…and 4 more, not listed.