Under another day of grilling on the witness stand — this time by Leora Shemesh, the lawyer for alleged violent kidnapper Alfredo Paladino — Pleterski was straight up accused of faking his entire abduction and beating over three days in December 2022.
“I’m going to suggest to you that (your friend) Clayton Soyka knew that your story of being kidnapped was a farce and that you and he discussed it after Dec. 8,” she said.
asserted
she → grill → Dec.
“I completely disagree with that,” the convicted fraudster replied in his now-infamous monotone.
asserted
fraudster → disagree → monotone
Pleterski, 28, was found guilty last month of defrauding investors of millions of dollars in a Ponzi scheme he ran as boy wonder crypto investor while living a champagne life of fast cars and private jets.
asserted
he → find → cars
Akil Heywood, one of the angry investors he cheated, is on trial for being the alleged “driving force” behind kidnapping Pleterski to recover his money.
asserted
he → cheat → money
Paladino and Rakeem Henry are accused of being the men who held him hostage and beat him.
asserted
who → accuse → him
All three have pleaded not guilty.
asserted
three → plead → ?
Pleterski’s story challenged by lawyers
Pleterski testified that he was lured to a meeting with “Slime” — the head kidnapper, who is not part of this trial — to discuss converting his crypto into cash and while held at gunpoint he said he recognized Heywood’s voice on the speaker phone warning it was the money or his life.
asserted
it → challenge → phone
Heywood’s lawyer Hussein Aly spent three days challenging his story including his claim that the investor had been threatening him before the abduction and that’s one of the reasons he hired bodyguards.
uncertain
he → spend → bodyguards
But if he was so afraid of him, the lawyer asked, why did Pleterski hire Jungle Lion Security run by Nessel “Chubbs” Beezer?
asserted
Pleterski → ask → Beezer
“Akil never threatened you,” Aly insisted, “just like he was never part of whatever happened with you and ‘Slime’ that day.”
asserted
whatever → threaten → you
Over three days, Pleterski said, he was pistol-whipped, punched, burned with a lighter, waterboarded and forced to his knees with a gun fired near his head.
asserted
he → say → head
He was also forced to give an apology confession, he said, to his duped investors that showed his face was swollen and covered with cuts.
asserted
face → force → cuts
“This is an apology that’s going to go to your very angry investors, right?
asserted
that → go → investors
See you with two black eyes so they have pity or sympathy for you, right?” Shemesh demanded.
asserted
Shemesh → see → you
“I didn’t know what they intended to do with the video,” he replied.
asserted
he → know → video
RECOMMENDED VIDEO
Friend gave alleged kidnapper a watch
Shemesh asked whether he sought any medical care for his injuries after being released by his alleged kidnappers outside the Ritz Carlton Hotel.
asserted
he → recommend → Hotel
Pleterski said he did not.
asserted
he → say → ?
She then asked about the curious relationship between his kidnapper “Slime” and his good friend Soyka.
asserted
She → ask → kidnapper
“You want people to believe that you never asked your friend Clayton about ‘Slime’ prior to meeting him.”
asserted
you → want → him
Pleterski maintained that he didn’t.
asserted
he → maintain → ?
Did he know his close friend Soyka met “Slime” at the Ritz on Christmas Day — weeks after the alleged kidnapping — and gave him a watch?
asserted
friend → know → watch
“It can’t be one of your watches?” Shemesh asked in a sarcastic tone.
asserted
Shemesh → ask → tone
I never gave Clayton any watches.”
asserted
I → give → watches
The lawyer intimated that Pleterski was paying off “Slime” for his role in the alleged kidnapping.
asserted
Pleterski → intimate → kidnapping
“I’m going to suggest to you that you asked Mr. Soyka to help you and that is why you sent him to go meet ‘Slime.'”
asserted
you → go → Slime
Shemesh also “suggested” Pleterski arranged the abduction to extort money from hotel executive Sandeep Gupta, who she alleged had been hiding millions of assets for him to elude the bankruptcy trustee and his many creditors.
uncertain
him → suggest → trustee
She pointed to a text from “Slime” to a phone given to Pleterski after he was dropped off, where he complains that he’d tried to help him.
asserted
he → point → him
“And the, ‘I tried to help you,’ isn’t ‘Slime’ telling you that he was trying to help you extract money out of Mr. Gupta.
asserted
he → try → Gupta
That couldn’t possibly be it?” Shemesh asked derisively.
uncertain
Shemesh → ask → ?
Her cross-examination continues Friday.
asserted
examination → continue → ?