Newly released jury notes from Lindsay Clancy’s triple-murder trial reveal what the foreperson told the judge that threw the case into chaos, ultimately ending in a mistrial.
asserted
that → release → mistrial
The notes, published Wednesday by Los Angeles Magazine, show that the jury foreperson repeatedly alerted Judge William Sullivan to concerns about a juror whom she claimed refused to follow the court’s instructions on the reasonable-doubt standard.
asserted
she → publish → standard
“A member of the jury is unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt.
asserted
member → follow → doubt
How should we proceed?” the foreperson wrote.
asserted
foreperson → proceed → ?
The foreperson, a retired elementary school teacher, spoke publicly just days following the mistrial.
asserted
foreperson → speak → mistrial
She criticized the prosecution and praised Clancy’s lead attorney, Kevin Reddington.
asserted
She → criticize → attorney
@LAmag has obtained the jury foreperson’s note that threw the Lindsay Clancy triple murder trial into chaos, ultimately leading to a mistrial.
asserted
that → obtain → mistrial
Clancy’s retrial is now scheduled for March 29, 2027.
asserted
retrial → schedule → March
A subsequent note was even more pointed, stating that the juror “has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states.”
asserted
law → state → verdict
“This is why we can not come to a unanimous decision,” the foreperson added.
asserted
foreperson → come → decision
The lone holdout juror publicly disputed that characterization.
asserted
juror → dispute → characterization
He said he had no reasonable doubt about Clancy’s guilt and favored conviction, while the other 11 jurors favored acquittal.
asserted
jurors → say → acquittal
LINDSAY CLANCY SECOND JURY NOTE: “Juror has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states.
asserted
law → make → verdict
This is why we can not come to a unanimous decision.”
asserted
we → come → decision
— Lauren Conlin (@conlin_lauren) November 18, 2026
During deliberations, Judge Sullivan individually questioned jurors about whether they could follow his instructions on the law.
uncertain
they → question → law
All said they could, including the holdout juror.
uncertain
they → say → juror
The judge ultimately rejected Reddington’s aggressive requests for further questioning of the holdout juror after receiving the foreperson’s notes.
asserted
judge → reject → notes
He instead reminded the jury of its obligation to follow his instructions on the law and sent the panel back to deliberate.
asserted
He → remind → panel
The trial ended in a mistrial on September 4 after jurors remained deadlocked.
asserted
jurors → end → September
Clancy’s attorneys now argue that the judge could have avoided a mistrial by investigating the allegations that the holdout was not following instructions and potentially replacing him with an alternate.
uncertain
holdout → argue → alternate
Sullivan rejected that argument in a November 9 ruling.
asserted
Sullivan → reject → ruling
He said the notes reflected disagreement among jurors and that further inquiry risked intruding into deliberations and coercing a verdict.
asserted
inquiry → say → verdict
The defense filed a petition with the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court on Monday, asking the court to reverse Sullivan’s ruling allowing a second trial and dismiss all three remaining murder charges.
asserted
defense → file → charges
The attorneys argue that retrying Clancy would violate her constitutional protection against double jeopardy.
asserted
retrying → argue → jeopardy
Clancy has admitted to killing her three young children, her attorneys argued at trial that she was not criminally responsible because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis.
asserted
she → admit → psychosis
Her retrial is scheduled to begin March 29, 2027.
asserted
retrial → schedule → ?
Related: Lindsay Clancy Is Headed Back To Court As Judge Sets Retrial Date
asserted
Judge → head → Date