Peter Meijer served as the U.S. representative for Michigan’s 3rd congressional district from 2021 to 2023.
asserted
Meijer → serve → 2023
He also served in the U.S. Army Reserves and, while a student at Columbia University, deployed to Iraq in 2010 to conduct intelligence operations.
asserted
He → serve → operations
As a member of Team Rubicon, he led humanitarian and crisis management efforts worldwide, including in New York after Superstorm Sandy, Oklahoma after a series of devastating tornadoes, and the Philippines following Super Typhoon Yolanda.
asserted
he → lead → Yolanda
In this Punch interview, he talks with Ben Domenech about the cascading failures of technology infrastructure across multiple U.S. industries, whether this is a sign that America is under attack, what response we should expect from our leaders, and what the American people can do to assuage their fears in an uncertain time.
asserted
people → talk → time
Let’s start with this.
asserted
’s → let → this
The general mood in the country right now seems to be one of panic, and it seems to be fomented by a lot of different elements of this and things that are combining to seem like a cascade of coincidences, which now makes people feel like they aren’t coincidences.
asserted
they → seem → coincidences
What’s your overall response to the way that this mood has grown, and what do you think is really behind it?
asserted
you → ’ → it
Obviously, this is before we get into what actually may be behind the outages and the disruptions.
uncertain
what → get → outages
Media loves a good story.
asserted
Media → love → story
Before, we were all worried about social media algorithms fine-tuning our dopamine receptors to continuously want something to happen.
asserted
something → worry → receptors
You have the idea that if it bleeds, it leads.
asserted
it → have → idea
So naturally, if something hit, those receptors are going to have the media amplifying it.
asserted
media → hit → it
And I also think that there’s just a generalized angst that — is it social media? Is it the threat of massive disruption?
asserted
it → think → disruption
Is it just the sort of technological era we’re living in?
asserted
we → live → era
We’ve had this generalized angst, in some ways — post 9/11 and, in other, more acute ways, post-COVID — in ways that I think we haven’t really fully reconciled with what that did to us as a society psychologically, that sense of waiting for the other shoe to drop, which, I spent time in finance and investments and in that broader market, there’s been this idea that the recession is just around the corner — it’s going to be the next 2008 global financial crisis.
asserted
it → have → corner
That has been the operating hypothesis across the markets for the better part of 15 years, which, ironically in some ways, the more you are worried about that thing happening, the more you’re keeping your guard up, the less you’re getting irrationally exuberant, the more you’re ironically decreasing the likelihood of that happening because you’re not taking the risks that could potentially precipitate this financial crisis.
uncertain
that → operate → crisis
So I think of that mentality and then porting it over to the broader culture where you have both some of the Frontier Lab CEOs and employees talking about how dramatically AI is going to change things sometimes in optimistic terms, oftentimes in less optimistic terms.
asserted
AI → think → terms
And then when you start to see this layered on, the disruptions that are explained and kind of waved away in the moment, but happening one after another, it not only cues into that greater concern and anxiety about where we’re going, but then it also hits upon a deeper mistrust in the institutions to the point where even all of the explanations that have been given so far are plausible.
asserted
that → start → explanations
They make sense on their face, and yet the trust is not there.
asserted
trust → make → face
How much of this is driven by a lack of knowledge, and therefore by ascribing enormous power to entities to affect lasting and immediate damage to major things people rely on?
asserted
people → drive → things
I’ve had more conversations in the last month about America’s power grid and the possibility of losing power for months at a time and things of that nature — people who’ve come up with reasons why that could happen.
uncertain
that → have → reasons
I’ve had more conversations about something I thought of as being an old thing that we used to worry about in my days in the War on Terror era of dirty bombs, most recently fomented again with this CNN report.
asserted
we → have → report
You’ve had a real attitude that everything happening is happening for a reason, and that it’s either driven by malevolent intent from overseas or by malevolent intent from independent hacking actors.
asserted
it → have → actors
Why do you think people jump to those conclusions instead of the conclusion I tend to jump to, which is that someone in the chain here was an idiot?
asserted
someone → think → chain
Well, just because you’re paranoid doesn’t mean they’re not watching you, or doesn’t mean they’re not following you.
asserted
they → ’re → you
So nothing I’m going to say should be interpreted as dismissing that or saying that I fully agree that all of these are just independent coincidences, but it is sort of a universal truism that a reason why conspiracy theories have purchase is that it’s a lot more soothing to believe that the things that are happening are happening because of intention than accident.
asserted
that → go → accident
And if you believe in a higher power that’s benevolent, that can help you make sense of and find peace with the world.
asserted
you → believe → world
If you believe in a greater power, a hidden force that is malevolent, that’s a lot more soothing than believing that, yes, somebody screwed up here.
asserted
somebody → believe → power
They didn’t think through this thing over there.
asserted
They → think → thing
Mistakes happen.
asserted
Mistakes → happen → ?
Have you met people?
asserted
you → meet → people
Sometimes they do a great job, other times they don’t.
asserted
they → do → job
That reality of the messiness of life is a difficult thing to grapple with, especially if you are having to understand that messiness within a very complicated, complex system that you not only do not understand, but some of the people who are experts and professionals in that also talk about not understanding.
asserted
who → grapple → that
And in that black box — and technology, AI, is the ultimate black box — in that black box, it is only natural to jump to the most problematic conclusions.
asserted
it → jump → conclusions
And that can actually be healthy if your assumption is that some malevolent force is going to try to manipulate a system, is going to hack into something that we’re all vulnerable to.
asserted
we → go → that
You take precautions that may go overboard at times, but in the main are entirely reasonable, entirely rational.
uncertain
that → take → main
And again, it could help forestall the very concern that you’re dealing with.
uncertain
you → help → that
So in this case, if it’s, “Hey, we had an outage over here; it was caused by an update.
asserted
it → ’ → update
We had another thing over here — the patch we implemented was a little rushed, so it didn’t have the results we were anticipating.”
asserted
we → have → results
You had something else occurring with a similar explanation…
asserted
something → have → explanation
…and 77 more, not listed.