Hey,
In 2016, I remember being at a dinner with my friend Rich Lowry, then editor of National Review and, hence, my boss.
asserted
I → remember → Review
Like the rest of my colleagues at National Review in those days, we were catching a lot of heat for not falling in line and supporting Donald Trump.
asserted
we → catch → Trump
Someone at the dinner asked, very politely, whether National Review would “come home” or “get on the Trump train,” or words to that effect.
asserted
Review → ask → effect
In the course of answering the question, Rich had to explain that National Review has a lot of diversity among its writers.
asserted
Review → answer → writers
Then he said something like, “Look, at the end of the day, what people need to understand is we’re not the RNC.”
asserted
we → say → what
What he meant by that was, wherever National Review as an institution ultimately came down, it would do so for its own reasons as an independent publication, not as an organ of a political party, and even then some writers were free to dissent.
asserted
writers → mean → party
This became something of a mantra for me when I got stuck in the same kinds of conversations.
asserted
I → become → conversations
I had written for years that I wasn’t really a “party guy” and didn’t want to be one.
asserted
I → write → years
For instance, I wrote a quarter century(!) ago:
asserted
I → write → instance
Well, this is as good a time as any to explain something.
asserted
this → explain → something
Indeed, if you asked me, I would be more likely to say I vote Republican or I tend to root for the Republicans.
asserted
I → ask → Republicans
I do this because I am a conservative and, like it or not, the Republican party is the party for conservatives.
asserted
party → do → conservatives
I know this statement bothers the six guys with a mimeograph machine over at the Howard Phillips office, but so be it.
asserted
it → know → office
But it just ain’t my bag.
asserted
it → ai → ?
Organized political enthusiasm — while necessary and noble — tends to annoy me when applied to large numbers of people, in much the same way I would rather stop an industrial fan with my tongue than ride a bus with the gang from Up With People.
asserted
I → tend → People
I’m not saying that I was perfectly immune to partisan zeal or team spirit.
asserted
I → say → zeal
So when Donald Trump became the GOP nominee, appeals to party loyalty really had very little purchase with me.
asserted
appeals → become → me
Back then, it was much easier to find people who agreed that Trump was terrible but Hillary Clinton was worse, and, therefore, I should vote for the lesser evil.
asserted
I → find → evil
I understood, and even had some sympathy for, that argument.
asserted
I → understand → argument
I can say without fear of contradiction that I was not a fan of Hillary Clinton.
asserted
I → say → Clinton
But even if I agreed with the argument that I should vote for Trump (and I didn’t—I wrote in Paul Ryan’s name), that didn’t mean I should behave like a comms person for the Republican National Committee.
asserted
I → agree → Committee
I cannot begin to explain how many people disagreed with this.
asserted
people → begin → this
Talk radio hosts mocked me.
asserted
hosts → mock → me
Fox News personalities would roll their eyes at my fastidious arrogance, disloyalty, self-indulgence, etc.
asserted
personalities → roll → arrogance
Serious and unserious people alike insisted that, once Trump got the nomination, it was my obligation to do everything I could to help him win or Hillary lose, as if I were a Republican politician.
uncertain
I → insist → everything
Now, I don’t actually believe that Republican politicians are morally required to support the nominee, but there is at least a very defensible argument for that.
asserted
politicians → believe → that
To the extent I was a Republican, my view then was Hamiltonian: “If we must have an enemy at the head of government, let it be one whom we can oppose, and for whom we are not responsible, who will not involve our party in the disgrace of his foolish and bad measures.”
asserted
who → have → measures
Well, you may have heard that I got into an online spat with the folks at The Bulwark.
uncertain
I → hear → Bulwark
For some fans of both publications, this felt like a tragic family squabble.
asserted
this → feel → squabble
That’s the thing about the tyranny of small differences: They aren’t small differences to the people on the inside of the conflict.
asserted
They → ’ → conflict
What started it was a video of Bulwark publisher Sarah Longwell at a Democratic Party conference in Colorado.
asserted
started → start → Colorado
She told the assembled Democrats, “You may know us, we’re the Never Trumpers.
uncertain
we → tell → us
Now we’re just kind of libs just like the rest of you.”
asserted
we → ’re → you
In response to the furor, Longwell tried to claim that she meant “classically liberal.”
uncertain
she → try → liberal
I think this was preposterous on its face.
asserted
this → think → face
No one in that room heard that and said to themselves, “Oh, she must mean like Lord Acton or Ludwig von Mises.”
asserted
she → hear → Acton
And Longwell certainly didn’t think the room full of Democratic partisans was a meeting of the Mont Pelerin Society.
asserted
room → think → Society
For a great many people, Longwell’s statement and her effort at damage control confirmed a widely held perspective that The Bulwark, which was founded in 2018 on the slogan that it was dedicated to “conserving conservatism,” had become more of a Democratic-aligned outlet than a, well, bulwark of conservatism.
asserted
it → confirm → conservatism
Kristol was once a fairly passionate pro-lifer, believing the goal of the GOP should be “an America in which every unborn child is protected in law and welcomed in life.”
asserted
child → believe → life
By 2024 he was weighing in on the side of Kamala Harris to use reproductive rights as a winning wedge issue.
asserted
he → weigh → issue
…and 75 more, not listed.