The city of Charlotte, North Carolina, is trying to make the wrongful death lawsuit over the horrific light-rail killing of Iryna Zarutska go away for good.
asserted
lawsuit → try → Zarutska
City lawyers asked a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge on Monday to throw out the suit.
asserted
lawyers → ask → suit
They argue the city is shielded by governmental immunity and can’t be blamed for the knife attack that ended the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee’s life aboard a Lynx Blue Line train last summer.
asserted
that → argue → train
The city wants the case dismissed “with prejudice” where possible, which would bar the family from ever refiling it.
asserted
which → want → it
The motion came weeks after a four-hour mediation session between Zarutska’s uncle and lawyers for the city and its transit security contractor ended in a stalemate, according to court papers.
uncertain
session → come → papers
It is the first time Charlotte has publicly answered the family’s accusations.
asserted
Charlotte → answer → accusations
Zarutska’s uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, filed the suit August 21, one day before the anniversary of her death.
asserted
uncle → file → death
He sued as administrator of her estate, naming the city and its contractor, Professional Security Services.
asserted
He → sue → city
The complaint paints a damning picture.
asserted
complaint → paint → picture
It says no guard was on the train when she was attacked, and that Brown rode without paying a fare.
asserted
Brown → say → fare
It also notes that the light rail has no turnstiles or gates.
asserted
rail → note → turnstiles
The family’s lawyer, Lauren Newton, argues that basic fare enforcement or properly staffed security could have saved Zarutska’s life.
uncertain
enforcement → argue → life
She also says the city had the money for all of it.
asserted
city → say → it
According to the suit, four people died on or near the Blue Line in the months before Zarutska was killed.
uncertain
Zarutska → accord → months
A judge will now decide whether to dismiss some, all or none of the claims against the city.
uncertain
judge → decide → city
If the motion is denied, the case will move forward.
asserted
case → deny → ?
Zarutska was heading home from her shift at a pizzeria on August 22, 2025, when she was knifed in the neck by a career criminal.
asserted
she → head → criminal
Surveillance footage of the attack sparked outrage nationwide.
asserted
footage → spark → outrage
Decarlos Brown Jr., a homeless man with a long rap sheet who once told cops he had schizophrenia, is accused of the slaying.
asserted
he → tell → slaying
He sits in federal custody, and a hearing in his state murder case has been pushed back to May 2027.
uncertain
hearing → sit → May
In the filing, city attorneys Lori Keeton and Terry L. Wallace called her death tragic and devastating but put the blame squarely on Brown.
asserted
attorneys → call → Brown
They denied that Charlotte “ignored passenger safety.”
asserted
Charlotte → deny → safety
The lawyers insisted the Charlotte Area Transit System already ran an “extensive security program” before the killing.
asserted
System → insist → killing
They said that included armed and unarmed guards and company police.
asserted
that → say → guards
Governmental immunity is one of 10 defenses the city raised.
asserted
city → raise → defenses
Its lawyers argue that policing trains and deploying security are core government functions that are protected from lawsuits.
asserted
that → argue → lawsuits
They also invoked the “public duty” doctrine, a legal principle that says local governments generally can’t be sued for failing to protect the public at large from criminals.
asserted
governments → invoke → criminals
The city also argued that the system-wide crime numbers cited by the family don’t prove a deadly attack like this one was foreseeable.
asserted
attack → argue → one
It called Brown’s alleged act an “independent, superseding cause” that breaks any chain of blame.
asserted
that → call → blame
City lawyers also pushed back on the claim that CATS is a for-profit business.
uncertain
CATS → push → profit
If the suit survives, Charlotte wants the judge to cap any payout at $1 million, the limit set by state law.
asserted
judge → survive → law