NBC News chairman Cesar Conde will headline the Committee to Protect Journalists's annual gala on Thursday after a rough year for the embattled group, which has been riven by infighting over its anti-Israel activism and controversial list of "journalists" slain in Gaza that brims with documented fighters for Hamas and other terrorist groups.
asserted
that → headline → Hamas
Conde will headline the CPJ's Press Freedom Awards Dinner gala—at New York City's Glasshouse—along with Lulu Garcia-Navarro, the New York Times podcast host, who will emcee the event for the group, which explicitly refers to Israel's conduct in Gaza as "a genocide."
asserted
which → headline → genocide
NBC News and the Times are big CPJ supporters, with Rebecca Blumenstein, NBC News's oddly titled "president, editorial," and the virulently anti-Israeli Times columnist Lydia Polgreen sitting on the CPJ's board.
asserted
Blumenstein → title → board
The gala—where benefactor tables run from $25,000 to $250,000—has long been an occasion for media executives and prestigious philanthropic foundations to showcase their support for journalists who risk their lives in the field.
asserted
who → run → field
But the New York-based advocacy group's most prominent media and corporate backers have little to say about the CPJ's drift into pronounced anti-Israel activism.
asserted
backers → base → activism
Every supporter contacted by the Washington Free Beacon either did not respond or declined to comment.
asserted
supporter → contact → Beacon
Pro-Israel groups, however, are speaking out.
asserted
groups → speak → ?
HonestReporting—an Israel-based media watchdog that has carefully tracked the CPJ's slain Gaza journalists list—told the Free Beacon that reputable journalists and their corporate bosses should be distancing themselves from the CPJ.
asserted
journalists → base → CPJ
"If the sponsoring organizations really want to protect their journalists, physically and professionally, they should explain why they believe CPJ deserves their support, or at the very least demand CPJ lives up to its mandate," the watchdog group said in a statement.
asserted
group → sponsor → statement
The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis, or CAMERA, has pushed back against the CPJ's "false claims" in recent months and told the Free Beacon that prominent CPJ allies like the Times and NBC have a journalistic duty to ask the advocacy group tough questions.
"
uncertain
allies → push → questions
In a few days, an NBC executive will chair CPJ's gala," CAMERA said in a statement.
asserted
CAMERA → chair → statement
"When scandals emerge, how can journalists so intimately tied to an advocacy group with flawed verification standards be expected to cover that group critically, as their profession demands?" the group asked in a statement.
asserted
group → emerge → statement
U.S. media observers told the Free Beacon that Conde's publicists may not have done their homework on the CPJ before sending him to the gala.
uncertain
publicists → tell → gala
Conde—best known for signing off on Rachel Maddow's $30-million-a-year contract to work one day per week—is an MBA, not a journalist, and works for the Roberts family, who control NBCUniversal and are supporters of Israel (the charitable foundation of Comcast chief Brian Roberts has given tens of thousands of dollars to Birthright, a group that sends young Americans on free trips to Israel, in the years after Oct. 7, 2023).
asserted
that → know → Oct.
Garcia-Navarro, in contrast to Conde, was NPR's Jerusalem bureau chief before joining the Times Opinion operation.
asserted
Navarro → join → operation
Earlier this year, the Times Opinion vertical published the outlandish Nicholas Kristof piece that alleged that two Palestinian "journalists" were raped—one by a dog and the other by a carrot—while in Israeli custody.
asserted
journalists → publish → custody
The piece has since been largely discredited, with Times executive editor Joe Kahn, who does not oversee the opinion team, saying he would not have published it.
asserted
he → discredit → it
The Free Beacon has repeatedly sought comment from the Times and NBC News over the last six months about their support for the CPJ as the committee battled attacks on its objectivity and credibility, but neither organization has responded.
asserted
organization → seek → objectivity
The CPJ's other major corporate and media backers also did not respond to requests for comment about whether they have reconsidered financial support to the CPJ as the scandal percolates.
asserted
scandal → respond → CPJ
This year’s ceremony—which has received past support from Google, Meta, News Corp, Microsoft, George Soros's Open Society Foundations, the Ford Foundation, Condé Nast, Thomson Reuters, Bloomberg, and the New York Times Company—comes at a precarious time for the 45-year-old advocacy group.
asserted
which → receive → group
The CPJ was thrust into disarray and infighting earlier this year after the Free Beacon published a series of reports showing that its influential list of "Journalist Casualties in the Israel-Gaza War" included numerous confirmed terrorists and Hamas militant fighters.
asserted
list → thrust → terrorists
Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, and other terror groups in Gaza have long disguised themselves as TV and radio journalists, much in the same way that Hamas operates from hospitals, schools, and mosques.
asserted
Hamas → disguise → hospitals
Many of these fighters, before they died, had posed for photos with weapons, flags, and regalia that clearly identified them as active militants, while others were commemorated in death by Hamas-produced "martyr videos."
asserted
others → die → videos
Nevertheless, the CPJ persisted in referring to many of these men as "slain journalists," writing on its website that "by silencing the press, Israel is silencing those who document and bear witness to what human rights groups and UN experts agree is a genocide."
asserted
groups → persist → witness
In late June, the CPJ's board of directors expelled anti-Israel heiress Nika Soon-Shiong after a heated meeting centered on a Free Beacon article about anti-Israel bias among CPJ board members.
asserted
meeting → expel → members
Despite Soon-Shiong's ouster, the group two days later held a 17-1 vote affirming that "organizations affiliated with militant groups" meet the criteria of a legitimate journalistic outlet "provided they are not engaging in combat or inciting violence in a manner likely to have imminent effect."
asserted
they → hold → effect
Only Fox News's board representative voted against this definition, which drew condemnation from outside media monitoring organizations.
asserted
which → vote → organizations
The board "voted to affirm our definition of who is a journalist," proclaimed a defiant Polgreen, who is the CPJ board's vice chair.
asserted
who → vote → definition
In the lead-up to its annual gala, the CPJ also conducted an internal review of its slain Gaza journalists list, hoping to assuage concerns that it was feeding into Hamas propaganda by eulogizing terrorists and accusing Israel of intentionally killing journalists.
asserted
it → conduct → journalists
While the CPJ initially said its internal review would be completed in July, the organization did not publicly disclose its findings until late September.
asserted
organization → say → September
The CPJ ultimately removed 19 terrorists and 3 other fake journalists from the list but reinstated 4 others who had been nixed for engaging in terrorism against Israel.
asserted
who → remove → Israel
That left a total of 191 supposed Gazan journalists on the CPJ's rejiggered database—102 of whom still have demonstrable "connections to terrorist groups," according to an independent review of the CPJ audit performed by HonestReporting.
uncertain
database—102 → leave → HonestReporting
The CPJ's newly revised list still includes Anas al-Sharif, who Polgreen wrote was "a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist" who was "assassinated" by Israel, "a young man who had suddenly become the face and voice of the desperate people of his homeland, Gaza."
asserted
who → revise → homeland
Though the IDF released voluminous documentary evidence to show that al-Sharif was an active Hamas soldier—including a photo of him hugging October 7 mastermind Yahya Sinwar—
asserted
him → release → Sinwar
Polgreen said Israel had "no credible evidence" for its case.
asserted
Israel → say → case
"The Committee to Protect Journalists is supposed to do just that, protect journalists, and, by extension, journalism.
asserted
Committee → suppose → extension
By counting terrorists as journalists they do the exact opposite," HonestReporting told the Free Beacon.
asserted
HonestReporting → count → Beacon
"CPJ puts journalists in harm's way and cheapens the professional credentials of actual journalists.
asserted
CPJ → put → journalists
Any press organization that lends its name to CPJ, or quotes their work uncritically, does exactly the same thing.
asserted
that → lend → thing
Until CPJ corrects the record and changes its methodology, no self-respecting journalist or reputable publication should have anything to do with them."
asserted
journalist → correct → them
…and 17 more, not listed.