Routinely “taking the piss” out of more privileged friends is one of the main ways people cope with a class difference in their friendships, research has found.
asserted
research → take → friendships
Cross-class friendships are widespread and mutually beneficial, a study by the London School of Economics showed, but a class gap can still pose an “omnipresent threat” to friendships.
asserted
gap → show → friendships
More privileged friends often provide financial support or cultural guidance to less privileged friends navigating elite spaces, the research found, and in return get a better understanding of the world outside their immediate sphere.
asserted
research → provide → sphere
But because the more tangible support tends to flow one way, it often brings about feelings of inequality or indebtedness, said the sociologist Prof Sam Friedman, who co-wrote the research.
asserted
who → tend → research
In some cases, it becomes a source of tension or sends friendships into a downward spiral, said Friedman, the author of The Class Ceiling and Born To Rule, which explored how the British elite has changed over the last 120 years.
asserted
elite → become → years
He and Prof Rose Butler, from Deakin University in Australia, looked at successful and failed cross-class friendships and found that those that lasted exhibited “class diplomacy”.
asserted
that → look → diplomacy
This involved making jokes, prioritising friendship over class differences and building empathy through talking about class differences.
asserted
This → involve → differences
A working-class man referred to as Peter in the study described making jokes about his friend, Julian.
asserted
man → refer → friend
“It would be your typical private school boy jokes … and stuff like, I don’t know, about mummy and daddy’s credit card on a night out,” he said.
asserted
he → know → night
A working-class friend in a similar friendship said his more privileged friend’s reaction to these kinds of jokes made him respect him.
asserted
him → say → him
He said: “I think the humour’s really important because essentially … he was quite thick [skinned], he never like got pissy or anything.
asserted
he → say → ?
A lot of the time he would take it on the chin.”
asserted
he → take → chin
The paper’s starting point was two studies by economists in the US and UK that analysed billions of friendship ties on Facebook and said that cross-class friendships were a good thing because they gave working-class people social capital that propelled them towards upward social mobility, Friedman said.
asserted
Friedman → analyse → mobility
He and Butler tested this claim using 42 in-depth interviews and found that humour was often pivotal to defusing tension.
uncertain
humour → test → tension
One friend from a background self-described as “upper middle class” and “elitey”, said: “The having a laugh thing is such a big deal … like the therapeutic way of managing [the class difference] …
asserted
thing → describe → difference
He’ll take the piss out of me but it’s fine.”
asserted
it → take → me
Other more privileged friends would make jokes at their own expense.
asserted
friends → make → expense
One working-class person in the study said about her friend from a wealthy background: “Every time I discovered a new house [that her family owned] I’d be like ‘Jesus Christ’ and would just let it slip, but both Sophie and me take the piss out of it.
asserted
Sophie → work → it
Like she’ll rip herself apart … she always does it before I can.”
asserted
I → rip → it
Friedman said the humour in successful friendships never resorted to “punching down”.
asserted
humour → say → friendships
“It’s punching up that works,” he said.
asserted
he → punch → ?
Some friends coped with the difference by not discussing class.
asserted
friends → cop → class
Less privileged friends talked about not wanting to call out snobbery.
asserted
friends → talk → snobbery
One middle-class person said about their less privileged friend: “I don’t think we really ever mention class.
asserted
we → say → class
But I think we’re hyper aware of the difference.
asserted
we → think → difference
It feels like it’s conferred such real-life advantages and disadvantages that it almost is so difficult to speak about.”
asserted
it → feel → advantages
Another friend from a less privileged background said: “I think he had a lot of learning to do and I think when both of us started to get to know one another, both his side realising how unbelievably lucky he’s had it, but on the flip me not being such a judgmental prick … it went both ways.”
asserted
it → say → flip
Friedman also identified that “the emotional burden of confronting class difference often fell disproportionately on friends from less advantaged backgrounds”.
asserted
burden → identify → backgrounds
“This was partly due to the fact that most of these friendships had emerged in middle-class spaces where middle-class norms were dominant and often taken for granted,” according to the paper, published in the journal Social Forces on Wednesday.
uncertain
norms → emerge → Wednesday
“Such inequality was best encapsulated by the idiom ‘a chip on the shoulder’ – the idea that someone is habitually (and unreasonably) bitter because they feel they’ve been treated unfairly – and is normally deployed on the basis of social class in Britain.”
asserted
they → encapsulate → Britain
Friedman said working-class interviewees often described this phrase being used against them by their friends at some point, “or feared that it might be used against them”.
uncertain
it → say → them