Eddie's dead: What one monarch's ill-fated journey can teach us about migration patterns
asserted
journey → teach → patterns
Also: Why sewing is having a moment
Welcome to our weekly newsletter where we highlight environmental trends and solutions that are moving us to a more sustainable world.
asserted
that → have → world
Hey, it’s Bryce.
asserted
it → ’ → ?
I became monarch-obsessed as they boomed this summer on the Prairies.
asserted
they → become → Prairies
I documented scientists attaching radio trackers to the endangered butterflies.
asserted
I → document → butterflies
I continue to follow their migration to Mexico on the Project Monarch app — including the journey of one nicknamed Eddie.
asserted
I → continue → one
What one monarch's ill-fated journey can teach us about migration patterns
- The Big Picture: Mapping freshwater threats
- Sewing is having a moment.
asserted
Sewing → teach → moment
Here’s why
Eddie's dead: What one monarch's ill-fated journey can teach us about migration patterns
asserted
journey → ’ → patterns
A monarch butterfly, nicknamed Eddie by researchers, sports a new radio tracker and antenna on its back after being trapped, tagged and released at the Living Prairie Museum in Winnipeg on Aug. 26.
asserted
butterfly → nickname → Aug.
It was the first time monarchs — 29 in total — have been tagged with such transmitters on the Canadian Prairies as part of a Canadian Wildlife Service project.
asserted
monarchs → tag → project
Lauran Burns had the highest of hopes for a butterfly she nicknamed Eddie.
asserted
she → have → butterfly
He was the first of 29 endangered monarchs that she and scientists in Winnipeg outfitted with toothpick-sized solar powered radio trackers using eyelash glue, then set free to migrate to central Mexico.
asserted
she → outfit → Mexico
But after a remarkable 1,200-kilometre flight, Eddie's signal went dark in early October — at the edge of a cul de sac near a cemetery southwest of Kansas City.
"
asserted
signal → go → City
I feel like we connected to Eddie more than the others," said Burns, conservation program manager at the Assiniboine Park Zoo in Winnipeg.
asserted
Burns → feel → Winnipeg
"[There's] a sad acceptance, I guess, that it's likely he's not going to make the full trip.
asserted
he → be → trip
Data from Project Monarch and Environment and Climate Change Canada shows the migration path of two of the 29 butterflies tagged in Manitoba — including Eddie, who was southwest of Kansas City as of Thursday, and MB26011, who made it to Mexico on Tuesday.
asserted
who → show → Tuesday
Those that make the full trip converge by the millions at a mountaintop World Heritage Site of oyamel fir forests in central Mexico, where they rest until spring.
asserted
they → make → spring
Far fewer have made the pilgrimage south in the past 15 years or so.
asserted
fewer → make → years
"About 15 to 20 years ago … there were so many, it was like every 10 feet, if you ran through the clover, it was like a dust of monarchs coming up," said Teddie Laframboise, who farms primarily hay in the south of Ottawa.
asserted
who → be → Ottawa
"It seems to have been going down and down, and I actually thought there was a little reboot this year, but nothing like before."
asserted
I → seem → ?
The species was red-listed as endangered in 2022 by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature.
asserted
species → list → Nature
There are also mysteries around the spectacular and perilous monarch migration that scientists are beginning to disentangle, thanks to the tiny transmitters.
asserted
scientists → be → transmitters
The solar-powered backpacks transmit at the same frequency as Bluetooth, so as butterflies flutter along, their signals ping off radio telemetry towers and people's cellphones.
asserted
signals → power → towers
Those signals are beamed to the Project Monarch app, where you can track and set alerts for any of the hundreds tagged across the U.S. and Canada this year.
asserted
you → beam → U.S.
The radio-tagging in Winnipeg this summer was the first time it's been done on the Prairies.
asserted
it → do → Prairies
It's part of a broader monitoring effort by Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), University of Guelph, Assiniboine Park Zoo and others over the past couple years focused on identifying migration patterns and pathways.
asserted
It → focus → patterns
As of Monday, at least 17 (60 per cent) of the Prairie monarchs' signals had gone dark, 10 had made it into Mexico (30 per cent) though not all had arrived yet to their overwintering grounds.
asserted
all → go → grounds
For the monarchs that make it, Burns says the data could highlight important stopover spots where they rested or fuelled up on nectar.
uncertain
they → make → nectar
From there, scientists might be able to better push for protections for those habitats.
uncertain
scientists → push → habitats
"You can start to look for trends — you know, are there areas [where] a lot of them stop emitting signals?" said Burns.
asserted
Burns → start → signals
"Maybe there's too big of a gap in the habitat they need or maybe they don't have that refuelling point to carry on.
asserted
they → be → point
The number of monarchs that don't make it from different regions will also reveal something important, said Greg Mitchell, a research scientist with Environment and Climate Change Canada in Ottawa.
asserted
Mitchell → make → Ottawa
"It's going to help us better understand where the pinch points are," said Mitchell.
asserted
Mitchell → go → ?
"The survival data is actually probably going to play a really big part in our understanding of the population dynamics."
asserted
data → go → dynamics
Mitchell co-chairs the Trinational Monarch Conservation Partnership between Canada, the U.S. and Mexico.
asserted
Mitchell → co → Canada
Though ECCC has only been tracking monarchs for a couple of years and the data still hasn't been fully analyzed, Mitchell notes subtle details are emerging that point to inclement weather as a possible increasing threat factor.
asserted
that → track → factor
He says last year there were drought conditions and intense wind events in the Kansas region, not all that far from where Eddie's signal last beeped.
asserted
signal → say → region
"It happened a couple times where there were these stall-outs because of really strong winds in the opposite direction to which they're moving.
asserted
they → happen → which
We lost some," said Mitchell.
asserted
Mitchell → lose → some
"That suggests to me … the weather that they're actually experiencing now might have changed through time with climate change, and so that's going to be really important to look into," he said.
uncertain
he → suggest → change
…and 66 more, not listed.